Showing posts with label track. Show all posts
Showing posts with label track. Show all posts

Wednesday, June 16, 2010

Outdoor Track

I've mentioned that the outdoor layout will be set in early 1880s Leadville (front yard) and Salida (back yard). Currently my target date is 1882, but I've wavered a bit on that. I'll comment more on that (someday) in a post on the outdoor layout design, but for this post let's focus on the track.

I've mentioned before that most outdoor track is "gauge 1" but the track style varies depending on whether we are modeling narrow or standard gauge. Because I am modeling 3 foot narrow gauge, my official scale is Fn3 -- "F" (1:20.3 scale), "n" = narrow, 3 = 3 feet. There is a lot of track available for Fn3 modelers, including Llagas Creek and Sunset Valley (I'd link to Sunset Valley's site, but they are having apparent site problems right now.) There are other manufacturers, but those tend to be the most respected in terms of "authenticity" of appearance.

Alas, I have two problems with their track. First, is cost. Over $3/foot for a normal section of track from the former, over $5/foot for the latter. Ok, maybe I could live with that, given that I spent over $1k on the Aquascapes stuff for the pond. But the second problem is that their appearance matches NG (narrow gauge) track in the 1900s, which granted is the era most people model. But in the 1870s and early 1880s this was what the track looked like:



That's Palmer Lake not long after the Rio Grande RR first came through. Look at those ties -- not a nice rectangular one in the lot. Tie plates? Not even sure they were invented then. And given the HUGE drive to make NG track as low cost as possible to appease the northeast financiers, tie plates would have been avoided as an unnecessary luxury. And ballast? We don't need no stinking ballast!

The truth was the NG movement in the U.S. from 1870-1883 was based largely on a myth of cost savings, and those constructing the railways were determined to ring out the cost savings even it it meant sacrificing long-term high maintenance costs in exchange for short term construction costs.

By 1882 in Leadville things probably weren't so extreme, but alas I can't find any pictures of the track at that time. I can find some of Salida in 1880 (when the railroad first came to Salida and Leadville) and 1882 and it appears that in 1882 they were still using 7-foot wide NG ties, but they were somewhat more rectangular in shape. Of course new ties would have been swapped out for the original ones -- put straight into the dirt the original ties would have needed replacement very early.

By 1882 the Rio Grande was already coming to terms with the need to put standard gauge rails to any city where there was competition from other standard gauge lines. In 1880 they added a 3rd rail to the front range line, and by 1890 they would do the same to Leadville, in response to the arrival of the standard gauge Colorado Midland.

But having said that, in 1882 the Rio Grande would also have been counting on having to replace the ties several times before they needed to add standard gauge to Salida/Leadville, so I figure 7' ties are just about right. Also, when the railroad first came through ties were built from local wood. The local wood was quickly exhausted however (in Palmer Lake the foresters talk about the 1870s as a time when everything was clear cut, and the oldest trees today date from that decade), so ties had to be bought from external sources -- and usually those were more conforming to a rectangular shape than the ones that were hastily cut when the line was first laid.

So, for my track I want: 7-foot scale, very rough ties; light rail (to match the rail then used), and more of a sand-dirt roadbed than anything resembling ballast.

I am considering fashioning my ties from old bits of pressure-treated (p.t.) fir from the bridge project, with some kind of additional sealant to make them last longer. For rail, looking at the table of rail sizes (see third table from the bottom) and recognizing that early Rio Grande rail was 30 lbs, later to 40 lbs, I will probably go with the smallest rail I can find that can support standard flanges -- maybe code 205.

For the roadbed I am considering stained concrete, with sand put on to make it look like the dirt/sand roadbed at the time. I'm now working on marking out and leveling the subroadbed area for the first loop of track that I will lay. Once that is in place I can experiment with handlaying roadbed and track using these materials.

If that is successful I can start working on handlaying a stub switch (scroll to bottom of page) -- which was the cheaper form of switch that was common on NG railroads back then.

    Monday, February 15, 2010

    Choosing N scale track: Flex Track and Switches

    Edit from the future (2021):  The price situation is very different from what it was when I wrote this 11 years ago.  Peco is no longer at a disadvantage.  Please check your own prices.

    Last year I posted an overview of types of N scale track. In this post I'll focus on one type of track in particular: flex track, and the related topic of switches. In theory any switch can be mated with any type of flex track, but in practice there are limitations. For many brand combinations the work to connect the two types of track is onerous and kludgy. You might, for example, connect two incompatible types of track in a few places for, say, a transition from staging to the main layout or from a main line to a branch line, but not as something you'd do for every switch. In addition, there is an appearance question, as certain lines of switches look out of place when connected to certain lines of flex track. The purpose of this post is to cover just those brands of N scale flex track and switches widely available in the U.S. Regarding the below references to track "codes", see my earlier post on that topic. Atlas Code 80. The granddaddy of N scale track, now distinguished from other track lines by its cheap price (good) and unrealistic appearance (not so good). A wide variety of switches are available, but nothing larger than a #6. There is also a wide variety of crossings and sectional track. Some people still use Atlas code 80 because they have experience with it and know it works. Others choose it for staging and hidden track, where appearance is not important. In addition to appearance the common complaint about Atlas code 80 is lack of switch reliability. This can be addressed with certain switch prep procedures, as I've covered in an earlier post, and in addition Atlas has improved the switches in the past couple years. Atlas code 80 can be easily mated with all Peco track. Atlas Code 55. Probably the most popular choice for N scalers using flex track in North America today. This is because it is price competitive with the other options, except Atlas code 80, yet the appearance is much better. There are also a wide variety of switches, crossings, and sectional track available in this line, including a #5, a #7, and a really cool looking #10 switch. Atlas also just announced two curved switches. There are still no slip switches, but given the number of recent extensions of the code 55 line that may change. Criticisms of Atlas code 55 are: 1) the plastic molded "spikes" which hold the rails in place are oversized, 2) because of (1) cars which run the Micro-Trains "pizza cutter" wheels (that is, those with a high flange profile) can't run on Atlas code 55, and 3) although the switches have a nice wire for the frog, it tends to corrode and lose contact, so you still have to add your own frog wire. (See earlier post about frogs and switches.) None of these criticisms are severe. For (1), while the spikes are oversized if you look closely, from a distance it's not noticable. For (2), most people who use Atlas code 55 are likely to use lower profile wheels which avoids the problem. And for (3), this can be taken care of easily during installation. Atlas code 55 mates reasonably well with Micro-Engineering code 55, so some people like to use M-E flex track with Atlas switches. Micro-Engineering (M-E). Micro-Engineering prides themselves on making high quality products, both in terms of appearance and reliability, and that is a good description of their code 70, 55, and 40 lines of N-scale track. They offer these with weathered or non-weathered rail, and with concrete ties for the larger two sizes. They also are the only manufacturer to offer a bridge tie version of their flex track, which is important because bridge ties are very different than normal track ties (roughly twice the tie density, and a different shape). All this variety allows a modeler to include different rail sizes for different areas of the layout, as is typical in the prototype. M-E was historically the most expensive track but that situation is no more. The UK firm Peco raised prices extensively in the 2000s, in part due to the declining dollar, and now is more than 50% higher than M-E. Based on my recent price samples M-E now seems roughly in the same price range as Atlas code 55 flex track (Atlas has also had a few price increases on track in recent years). The only complaint I've ever heard about the track itself is minor -- a few people say it is harder to bend than the other brands. The main complaint about the line of track, other than the price, is that the switch offerings are so spartan: just a #6 switch for code 55 and 70, and if you want a code 40 switch you have to make it yourself. Because of the superior appearance of track but lack of switch choice many modelers use M-E code 55 with Atlas code 55 switches, and the two rail sizes match up reasonably well. However, if you want the epitome of best appearance for your track, the choice is probably M-E plus hand-laid switches, and for that M-E also offers supplies for those who build their own switehcs. Peco code 80. For a while the Peco code 80 line was considered the best choice in track, before the other sub-80 lines were introduced. It is considered somewhat better in appearance than Atlas code 80, and their code 80 switches are considered much more reliable than Atlas code 80. Because the Atlas and Peco rails work well together it used to be common for modelers to use the cheaper Atlas code 80 flex with the better Peco code 80 switches, and some Ntrak clubs still use this as their standard. Peco also offers a wide variety of switches, including the only slip and curve switches in code 80, as well as crossings, sectional track, and even a derail. (Note: there are actually two compatible lines of Peco code 80 track -- the cheaper SEtrack and the more expensive Streamline. I'm only covering Streamline in this review, as SEtrack is very hard to get in the U.S.) Their switches include a "spring" for snapping to one side or the other, which can be removed to install a slow motion switch machine. In code 80 they also offer "electrofrog" and "insulfrog" for all switches. Complaints about Peco code 80 switches are primarily from the American market because the UK N scale standards vary every so slightly from US standards, so that depending on the equipment you run you may have trouble with derailments or, if you use DCC, with occasional shorts. These seem pretty rare, but you do find them mentioned on comment boards, and there are standard suggestions for fixing this problem if you have it. The other issue with Peco, as noted earlier, is that the prices have skyrocketed in recent years and as a result they have nearly priced themselve out of the U.S. market. In HO, Peco has released American-style switches that are considered among the best you can buy, yet they have managed to keep the prices within reason. There have been rumors of a similar line for N scale, but nothing has yet been announced. Peco code 55. This line of track is highly unique, and so it has a longer write-up than any of the other lines. When Peco introduced this line in circa 1990 it was widely considered a huge advancement and the preferred choice for N scalers. Today, most modelers now see it as having been surpassed by M-E and Atlas, but there are still some unique advantages of Peco code 55, so it is not yet completely obsolete. When Peco code 55 was introduced there were a lot of commonly-held concerns about the viability of a small N scale rail. Peco addressed this by using code 80 rail but burying the bottom .25" into the ties. The track itself is very sturdy -- more than any other of the flex track offerings -- and the plastic tie "spikes" or "clips" are prototypically small, as they are used only for appearance, not to hold the track in place. There is a fake rail bottom at the top of the ties, then another one at the actual bottom of the rail. Peco code 55 track comes in wood or concrete, but just wood for the switches (AFAIK no one has yet come out with an N scale concrete tie switch yet). Peco 55 has almost the same large variety of switches and crossings as code 80, but all are "electrofrog". There is also a double-crossover with four built-in switches. Like code 80 the code 55 switches have springs which can be removed for slow-motion switch machines. Proponents like Peco code 55 for solidity, reliability, and wide variety of switch choices (this has become less of an advantage over time as Atlas has expanded their code 55 line). Detractors, and there are many, point to the high cost and appearance issues. Appearance issues start with the tie spacing, which matches a European prototype, not the U.S. The wood ties have a fake wood grain that is much too prominent. The switch mechanisms look nothing like prototype switches. The switches themselves are classified "small", "medium" and "large" instead of the more traditional #4, #6 and #8. This is because they do not follow the common U.S. practice of having the diverging rails go straight through the frogs, but instead are curved for the entire length of the switch. On the plus side, this difference means that the radius used for Peco code 55 switches is much wider than that use for competitive brands, and that the trains motion in going through the switch is more fluid. The "large" switch has a radius of 36", which is very broad (see earlier discussion of curves). But it is yet another deviation from the common American prototype. Finally, there are questions about code 55 switch reliability (there are concerns that the flangeway is too wide, leading to derailments), although there are many users who claim they work perfectly all the time. Given the cost issues Peco code 55 is usually not considered for new layouts any more. But thre are still a few willing to work through the appearance issues who find the variety of switches a compelling reason to choose this option.

      Thursday, April 30, 2009

      Choosing N scale track: Overview

      Edit from the future (2021): the price situation now is radically different than it was when I wrote this in 2009.  Peco is no longer at such a large disadvantage and has gained in popularity.  Please check your own prices when you read this.

      Once a modeler chooses N scale he/she then has to choose which brand (e.g. Atlas) and line (e.g. Code 55) of track to use. This decision has to come fairly early in the planning process as different brands/lines of track and switches have different geometries, thus impacting the layout design. This post provides an overview of what's available in the U.S. and Canada. In a later post I'll go into more detail on the topic of the different lines of flex track/switches, where there is a lot of choice and a lot of factors to consider. N scale track can be grouped into 4 categories. I'll list them here in order from beginner to most advanced:
      1. Roadbed Track & Switches
      2. Sectional Track & Switches
      3. Flex Track & Switches
      4. Hand-laid Track & Switches
      Note that Atlas and Peco offer lines of track that include both (2) and (3). When choosing your type of track these are the factors to consider. Ease of Use and Time to Install. This factor can vary tremendously from one category to the next. At the extremes consider that a sizeable roadbed track layout can be put together by a beginner in an hour or less, which is about as long as an expert needs to assemble a single hand laid switch. Appearance. In general, the trade-off for ease-of-use and time-to-install is appearance. The more time you invest in installing your track, the higher the potential quality of the appearance, depending upon your implementation. Nothing looks as sharp as quality hand-laid track, while no amount of scenic detail can fully hide the unrealistic plastic appearance of roadbed track. Price. In general, the most expensive category is roadbed track and each successive category is cheaper. There are, however, exceptions to this rule. Some sectional switches can be quite pricey, and many people who handlay track invest a lot in specialized handlaying tools and materials. Flexibility. With handlaid track you can create any configuration, curve, spiral, or switch geometry you need. With roadbed track you are limited to the pieces the manufacturer offers. Sectional track is a little more flexible than roadbed track in that you can cut pieces. Flex track is equivalent in this regard to hand-laid track except for the switches. Operational Reliability. All categories of track offer anywhere from poor to excellent reliability depending upon brand and installation quality. Within each category certain brands are better than others. So, with those decision factors in mind, here is a survey of each category of track: Roadbed Track includes a built-in plastic roadbed underneath the ties. The roadbed adds stability, but the main advantage is that you "click" one piece of roadbed track to another, so assembly as fast and the track stays locked together. The different brands of roadbed track are not compatible with one another, but you can construct a "transition" track between two makes if so desired. Each manufacturer offers a variety of lengths of straight track, plus a variety of curves in different lengths and radii, plus switches and special purpose track like crossings. Roadbed track is the preferred choice for starter sets and newcomers to the hobby, especially children. It's also popular for those modelers who prefer operations to construction and aren't overly concerned with appearance. The quick setup feature also makes it popular among those who need to tear down and rebuilt layouts frequently. And of course, all roadbed track features insulated switch frogs for ease of use. Historically all roadbed track has been code 80, and Kato has been the most popular manufacturer due to both their large variety of track and their reputation for impeccable operations reliability. Bachmann offers a smaller line of cheaper roadbed track that tends to get less favorable reviews for reliability, especially the switches. Life-like train sets include their own roadbed track, and apparently you can order extra pieces, but the selection is very limited. This past year Atlas has introduced a line of code 60 roadbed track that is clearly intended to compete with Kato for the lion's share of this market. Early reviews are that Atlas wins on price and appearance, but I have no experience with it. Sectional track is similar to roadbed track, but without the roadbed. The track consists of plastic ties and rails, and each manufacturer offers a variety of curves, straights, switches, and special track. Connections are purely by rail joiner, so if you use sectional track you'll want to at least pin it into place on a board, and most people install the sectional track on top of a roadbed material, like cork, then glue scale ballast on top to complete the effect and hold the track in place permanently. Because the connection is by rail joiner different makes often work interchangably with each other, if the rail size is the same, and even if they don't it's usually not hard to build a transition track between two makes. Makes that work together: Peco 80, Atlas 80 and Peco 55; Atlas 55 with Micro-Engineering flex track. Sectional track was available decades before the introduction of roadbed track 20 or so years ago. Many people, myself included, thought that sectional track would eventually be completely replaced by roadbed track, but it turns out that a lot of modelers like sectional track. A well-scenicked layout with sectional track can look very nearly as nice as one with flex track, but avoids the extra work and skills that flex track requires. There are apparently enough of these modelers that when Atlas released their new code 55 line 4 or 5 years ago they included a huge variety of sectional pieces, and they have been a big seller. Atlas flat-out dominates the sectional track market in North America, with code 80 and code 55 lines. Peco, a UK firm, once was very popular but has lost most of their market share due in large part to exhorbitant prices, recently made worse by the weak dollar. A few other makes have been available in the past, such as Shinohara (code 70) and Model Power, but their market share is almost non-existent now. For modelers building new sectional track layouts the choice is likely to be between Atlas code 55 and 80, although Peco code 55 and 80 may be an option for a few. I'll cover the differences between these lines of tracks in my future post on flex track, since all of these sectional track lines include compatible flex track as well. Flex track is a section of track 29-36" long (length depends on the manufacturer) that can be bent to shape. With flex track you can duplicate anything that you can do in sectional track, plus you can build curves of radii that are not available in sectional track, and even create curves of changing radii, such as spiral easements. Flex track is considered better in appearance than sectional track, in part because curves and spiral curve transitions can look more realistic, and in part because sectional track has too many rail joints and has funny looking partial ties at both ends of each track piece. With the exception of Micro-Engineering code 40 track, all flex track lines include compatible switches. In addition, as noted above, sectional track lines from Peco and Atlas offer compatible flex track. So, there is a large selection of flex track lines to choose from - more choice than available for sectional or roadbed track. Since it is not difficult to connect the different types of flex track (using a transition track if necessary) many modelers do just that. For example, using larger rail for main lines and smaller rail for branch lines and sidings. Flex track does require more work to install than sectional track. When laying sectional track the curves and straight lines are already built in. With flex track you have to mark curves and straights onto the roadbed, then carefully adjust the track to match the marks. Spiral easements -- in which the curve gradually transitions from a tangent to a curve or from one radius curve to another -- require more skill to create than constant radius curves. Flex track often has to be precisely cut to fit, with the rails often of different lengths due to curves. This task is harder in N scale than HO because there is less room for error. Then there is the fact that around curves flex track joints need to be soldered to keep the curve steady and without dents. None of these skills are hard to learn, but taken together one can understand why some modelers prefer sectional track. I will review the different lines of flex track in a future post. Hand-laid track is preferred by those who want the absolute best possible appearance. It's not nearly as common in N scale as it is in HO (the size factor makes it harder to assemble the smaller N scale parts together by hand), but it's not rare either. While there are those who hand lay both the track and the switches, its become more common recently for modelers to hand lay the switches in combination with their preferred flex track, usually choosing Micro-Engineering for appearance reasons. The advantages of hand laid switches are many. First, if done well the appearance can be nearly identical to the prototype. The difference is noticable enough that visitors with any model railroad knowledge at all will see and admire it. Second, custom switches can be built for any situation. Need a switch with a #9 frog, or an outside switch on a 28" radius curve, or a crossing of a curved track and a straight one? None of these are available unless built by hand. Price is also an advantage, at least theoretically, as you are just buying rails, ties, spikes and/or glue and/or solder. In practice many modelers who hand lay track invest in specialized tools and jigs, or even buy partially assembled switches that have the rails and a few key ties in already in place -- all of those things save time and help make for reliable switches, but also cost money. The down side is that this is a lot of effort and time. And while proponents of hand-laying are correct to say that anyone can learn the skill, it's a skill that takes time to learn to do well. One noted hand-laying proponent, the prolific model railroad author Tony Koester, says that it takes him about an hour to assemble each of his hand-laid HO switches. (Tony's method is described in his Model Railroader book, Trackwork and Lineside Detail.) Others, such as the makers of Fast Tracks jigs for handlaying switches, say it can be done faster. I seriously considered handlaying my switches until i realized how long it would take to build the 130+ I will have on the main layout. At the rate of one switch per hour, and maybe 4-5 hours per week on the layout, that translates to at least half a year just assembling (not installing) switches. So I bought mine. But for those with smaller layouts, or with more time, who place an absolute premium on appearance this is your best option.

      Monday, April 13, 2009

      (not so) Secret Codes

      In past posts I've mentioned Code 80 and Code 55 track. In model railroading, "Code xx" simply means the height of the rail above the top of the ties (a.k.a. "sleepers" in the British Commonwealth) in thousandths of an inch. For example: Code 80 track has 0.080" high rails.

      "Why should I care about rail height?", you may ask. And many model railroaders happily build their layouts without ever worrying about rail height. However, it's just one more aspect of realism that a modeler may or may not be concerned about.

      The problem is that most model train track has rails that are ridiculously big, and although most people don't notice at first glance, if you are looking at a detailed model of a railroad scene the oversize rail can often ruin the illusion.

      In the prototype (a.k.a. "real life"), modern rails in the U.S. tend to all share the same flat-bottomed profile, as shown at the link. However, rail sizes can vary greatly. By convention, the rail size metric used is "pounds per yard" of rail. At one extreme, the early DRG narrow gauge lines used 30 lb. rail -- which is about 3 1/8" in height. At the other extreme the Pennsylvania Railroad (PRR) once used 155 lb rail for their main lines -- the heaviest rail in common use, and about 8" in height. Modern class 1 (the busiest main lines) rail tends to be in the 100-132 lb range (6-7 1/8" high), although some heavier rail (140 lb) is starting to be used. It's typical for a railroad to mix rail sizes -- sidings, spurs, branches and yards often have smaller rail -- often 80-90 lb or less.

      How does that compare to the model? Well, in N (1:160) scale Code 80 was long the N scale standard, and is still the most commonly used rail. Code 80 is equivalent to over 13" high rail -- about double the size of a modern main line. Code 55 is now the preferred rail for N scalers more interested in the details, but even that translates to 8.8" rail height -- bigger even than the PRR. Code 40 track is available for those that want absolute accuracy, as code 40 is equivalent to about 6.4" high track (roughly 110 lbs/yard), but if you use code 40 you have to hand build your own switches. Some modelers choose code 55 for the main lines and code 40 for spurs and sidings.

      How much difference does it make? Well, compare a photo of a prototype locomotive to its N scale equivalent sitting on code 80 track and you'll notice the difference right away -- of course, that's probably because you'll be looking for it. In practice, most people don't notice, especially if you "weather" your track by painting a rust color on the sides of the rails and do a good job with the ties and ballast. I have heard from one N-trak modeler who often takes his N-trak modules to conventions and he reports that no one noticed (or at least no one commented) when he converted to code 55 from code 80. However, he gets lots of comments when he makes other changes to the details.

      Still, I am using code 55 on my main layout, in large part because code 55 track products look a lot better overall, not just the rail height, than do the code 60, 70 and 80 N scale products.

      For the record, the reason N scale track manufacturers initially chose code 80 was operations reliability. As with all model train scales, oversize rail and wheel flanges were chosen to minimize derailments. Today, modern plastic and metal manufacturing techniques are much more precise than they were in the past, so we can acheive even better operational reliability without the oversized rails and flanges. Even so, there are potential operational issues with certain brands of N scale code 55 track, and I'll cover that in a later post on track brands.

      For those interested in more details on rail heights and sizes in the prototype and in the model scales, here is a good site.

      For those interested in very high accuracy model railroading, what is commonly called "fine scale" modeling, the Proto 87 site is worth a visit. The term "Proto 87" simply means trying to precisely and accurately model the prototype in HO (1:87) scale. In addition to getting the rail size right, they also try to model exact replicas of (for example) switches and wheel flanges. This type of modeling is not for everyone, as there is a lot of extra effort required. But its a lot of fun to look at the results of a successful Proto87 modeler.